DC K.O.: SUPERMAN VS. CAPTAIN ATOM #1 - Review

• Written by: Joshua Williamson

• Art by: Sean Izaakse

• Colors by: Trish Mulvihill, HI-Fi

• Letters by: Dave Sharpe

• Cover art by: Jorge Corona, Sarah Stern (cover A)

• Cover price: $4.99

• Release date: December 3, 2025

DC K.O.: Superman vs. Captain Atom #1, by DC Comics on 12/3/25, tests whether big superhero showdowns can deliver when the plot relies on a cosmic game that seems designed to corrupt everyone who enters it.

First Impressions

Captain Atom's monologue about embracing his true destiny hits with confidence and swagger, setting him up as a formidable challenger to Superman. The opening pages establish real tension between these two characters, but the tension evaporates once the tournament logic takes over. Sean Izaakse's art keeps the action kinetic and readable, though the dialogue sometimes struggles to balance Captain Atom's cocky determination with Superman's reluctant participation.

Plot Analysis

The comic opens with Captain Atom confidently introducing himself as Nathaniel Christopher Adam, a soldier reborn with godlike power through a mysterious military experiment. He's ready for the tournament because winning means possessing the power to kill Darkseid and save reality itself. Superman confronts him about taking out Supergirl in the previous round with friendly fire, and Captain Atom justifies his ruthlessness by arguing they're at war and sacrifices must be made. The Heart (the tournament's cosmic arena) teleports them to Metropolis for a best-of-three boxing match, where both fighters struggle with the moral weight of throwing down while invisible civilians might be watching.

In the second round, both fighters escalate dramatically. Captain Atom unleashes red sun energy and kryptonite against Superman, forcing the Man of Steel to seek an alternative strategy. Superman transforms into Superman Prime from the 853rd Century, and Captain Atom shifts into Monarch, a god-like being from an alternate timeline with control over time and space. The two fight across Superman's hometown, where Captain Atom continues his assault and Superman desperately tries to avoid becoming as ruthless as the tournament demands. Superman discovers that extreme cold can slow down atoms and quantum fields, and he uses his solar power reserves to outlast Captain Atom in an escalating stalemate.

In the third round, both fighters choose new forms, but the fight becomes genuinely confusing. Superman decides to remain himself rather than accept another form, believing the Heart is corrupting them both and wanting to preserve his identity. Captain Atom sees this as weakness and becomes even more aggressive with his determination to win. During their clash, Captain Atom creates what appears to be an atom bomb by sacrificing his own history and timeline, destroying his past to gain control over his future. Superman and Captain Atom's powers somehow combine in this explosion, and Superman manages to drain Captain Atom's remaining energy, forcing him to explode and teleport away from the tournament in an uncontrolled fashion.

Writing

The pacing starts strong during Captain Atom's opening monologue, which effectively establishes his philosophy and motivation. However, once the tournament begins, the writing becomes clunky and exposition-heavy. The dialogue often explains what we're seeing in the art rather than revealing character through natural conversation. The three rounds feel repetitive rather than escalating, and the third round's resolution is genuinely hard to follow. Superman's decision to remain himself makes thematic sense, but the mechanics of how that decision defeats Captain Atom remain murky. The comic tells us Superman combined their powers and drained Atom's energy, but it never clearly explains how that happened or why Atom couldn't rewind time as he claimed to do.

Art

Sean Izaakse delivers solid, kinetic action sequences with clear panel-to-panel storytelling throughout most of the fight. His layouts emphasize the impact of each punch and energy blast, and his character expressions convey emotional stakes. The color work by Trish Mulvihill and HI-FI shifts appropriately between scenes, from the cool tones of Metropolis to the warmer, more chaotic atmosphere of the combat arena. However, the third round becomes visually confusing. The transformation sequences and the final explosion lack the clarity of earlier rounds, making it difficult to understand what's actually happening physically. The shift between the two colorists partway through the issue doesn't help consistency.

Character Development

Captain Atom's arc is the more interesting of the two. He begins as a soldier who views the tournament pragmatically, willing to make ruthless sacrifices because he sees his entire military career as one long series of losses and rebuilds. That makes his willingness to destroy his own history somewhat believable, though it still feels abrupt. Superman remains frustratingly passive throughout. He objectively has the stronger hero's arc (refusing to compromise his identity), but the writing doesn't give him enough agency to make this feel earned. He mostly reacts to Captain Atom's aggression rather than actively choosing a different path. His trust in his friends feels tacked on rather than foundational to his decision. Neither character's consistency holds up under scrutiny, particularly in the third round where Superman's refusal to transform somehow gives him advantage without clear explanation.

Originality & Concept Execution

The core concept of a tournament where heroes must choose corrupting forms to win sounds fresh, and Captain Atom's character arc within that structure offers genuine thematic meat. The premise is executed well through the first two rounds. However, the third round abandons the central premise almost entirely. Instead of choosing forms and fighting within the Heart's rules, Captain Atom suddenly decide to battle the Heart itself an Superman refuses to engage with it fully, which sidesteps the tournament's central conflict rather than resolving it. This makes the comic's final resolution feel like a cheat rather than a earned climax.

Positives

The action sequences in rounds one and two are genuinely engaging, with Izaakse's dynamic compositions making every panel feel impactful and exciting. Captain Atom's character voice is distinctive and compelling. The voice acting in his monologue and his dialogue throughout conveys real personality and conviction, making him feel more three-dimensional than many tournament fighters. The central thematic conflict between personal survival and maintaining moral integrity is meaningful, and Superman's choice to preserve his identity rather than transform offers real emotional weight. The comic also successfully sets up stakes for future rounds by establishing that the Heart itself might be more dangerous and complex than initially understood.

Negatives

The third round falls apart. The resolution is confusing, with the comic never clearly explaining how Superman went from defensive and struggling to suddenly winning by draining Atom's power. The mechanics of Captain Atom's ability to sacrifice his timeline and create an atom bomb contradict his earlier statements about his own powers and limitations. Superman's victory doesn't follow logically from the story's established rules. The ending twist revealing Darkseid's potential involvement in the tournament happens too late to have proper weight, and it contradicts earlier dialogue about the Heart's function. Additionally, the pacing in the final third becomes rushed and disorienting, with quick cuts between scenes that make the climax feel more chaotic than intentionally designed.

About The Reviewer: Gabriel Hernandez is the Publisher & EIC of ComicalOpinions.com, a comics review site dedicated to indie, small, and mid-sized publishers.

Follow @ComicalOpinions on YouTube, Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter

The Scorecard

Writing Quality (Clarity & Pacing): [2/4]
Art Quality (Execution & Synergy): [3/4]
Value (Originality & Entertainment): [1/2]

Final Verdict

DC K.O.: Superman vs. Captain Atom #1 starts as a solid superhero grudge match with real thematic stakes but collapses under the weight of its own confusion in the third round. The first two rounds deliver exactly what the premise promises: high-impact action with meaningful character stakes. But when the comic finally reaches its climax, it abandons its own rules and delivers a resolution that contradicts earlier established mechanics. Captain Atom's ruthlessness versus Superman's moral conviction could have been genuinely compelling, but instead of earning a satisfying conclusion to their conflict, the comic opts for a resolution that leaves readers scrambling to understand what actually happened.

6/10

We hope you found this article interesting. Come back for more reviews, previews, and opinions on comics, and don’t forget to follow us on social media: 

Connect With Us Here: Weird Science DC Comics / Weird Science Marvel Comics

If you're interested in this creator’s works, remember to let your Local Comic Shop know to find more of their work for you. They would appreciate the call, and so would we.

Click here to find your Local Comic Shop: www.ComicShopLocator.com

---

As an Amazon Associate, we earn revenue from qualifying purchases to help fund this site. Links to Blu-Rays, DVDs, Books, Movies, and more contained in this article are affiliate links. Please consider purchasing if you find something interesting, and thank you for your support.