Tuesday, August 23, 2022

Detective Comics #1063 Review

 

  

The Deed is Done

Writer: V. Ram, Simon Spurrier
Artist: Rafael Albuquerque, Dani
Cover Price: $4.99
Release Date: August 23, 2022

While it seems that I am one of the few people who haven't fallen head over heels for Ram V's writing, I was cautiously optimistic after reading the last issue of Detective Comics, his first of the series.  Yea, it didn't hurt that he is following Mariko Tamaki's less than stellar time on the book, but the horror-tinged story felt like it was a good fit for him and Rafael Albuquerque.  So let's see if Detective Comics #1063 continues the upward trend...

Detective Comics #1063 opens with a nightclub scene with Harvey Dent and Bruce Wayne exchanging pleasantries and some over-the-top pretentious dialogue.  The voices of both characters felt off, but I have to admit, it is refreshing to see Batman being a little more assertive than he has been lately.




We then head to sea to see a couple of the (maybe) villains of the story, Shavhod, Arzen, and Neang.  The names roll off the tongue!  We get a better look at their land title deed for Gotham and more odd-sounding names ending in the more familiar Arkham.  The overall concept Ram V is giving us is not new (Curse of the White Knight dealt with a similar deal), but more disquieting is that it's not that exciting either.

Continuing with Batman sneaking into Blackgate Prison, Ram V is pushing the Bat-Narration big time.   While he might be going for a noir feel here, it just reads like someone trying too hard to get a classic Batman voice.  If you read it out loud, it sounds so silly and overdone.

The Dark Knight is in Blackgate to show Maestro the music box he found in the last issue and see if he can identify the melody.  While I like seeing underused characters get some spotlight, the scene plays too quickly, especially for the result to be so big...maybe.




I say maybe because Ram V is again giving readers a lot to digest but playing it so loose that by the end of the issue, I wasn't sure if I got too much or too little... or even anything!  Ram V seems more concerned with atmosphere and feel than the story and plot progression, which doesn't jive with me. 

The ending gives me hope of the return of a classic villain, but again, Ram V muddies it up way more than he needs to.




I was not fond of this issue much at all.  Ram V is busy giving the readers a slew of new characters that aren't very interesting and are taking page space away from Batman.  This issue looks excellent thanks to Rafael Albuquerque's art, but right now, the story is a bit of a convoluted and ill-defined mess.

I did not include the Si Spurrier backup story in my score below because I don't think it would be fair to Ram V.  The story is not good and isn't worth the extra dollar.  What I'm saying is it stinks!

Bits and Pieces:

Detective Comics #1063 is a downer as Ram V throws a lot at the reader but struggles with character voices and overall focus.  It looks great thanks to Rafael Albuquerque's stylized art, but it's a bit of a slog overall.

5.0/10

4 comments:

  1. 100% agree about both Ram V's story and Spurrier's. I don't think DC really cares about Detective at this point. And that's just sad.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Here is a funny thing I noticed this week - when you get an issue like this from Ram V, it puts the reviewers into "Pretentious Prose" mode in their reviews! It's like they grab the thesaurus to sound as fancy as the dialogue in the book!!!

      Delete
    2. But I honestly can't think what can they extract from this. Like, there is no substance here, nothing you can think of and ramble about. Hickman is pretentious as hell, Morrison used to be, but they put some ideas forward besides all their pretentiousness. Ram V does nothing here. He doesn't even come up with his usual shtick where he philosophizes for an entire book only to come up at the end with the "answer" that humans are awful but we need to move forward, like in his Swamp Thing. I don't think he's the worst writer out there, God knows there are A LOT worse than him, he's just bland and he lacks interesting ideas, it's all style over substance with him and once you've read one of his stories, you've read them all.

      Delete
    3. He is better than a whole lot of writers and fits on certain books - this should be working better, but you are right, there just isn't any substance to this!

      Delete