DC K.O. KNIGHTFIGHT #2 - Review

• Written by: Joshua Williamson

• Art by: Dan Mora

• Colors by: Triona Farrell

• Letters by: Tom Napolitano

• Cover art by: Dan Mora (cover A)

• Cover price: $3.99

• Release date: December 3, 2025

DC K.O. Knightfight #2, by DC Comics on 12/3/25, strips Batman down to his existential core, forcing him through a reality-warping gauntlet designed specifically to break his psyche.

First Impressions

The opening hits with an almost claustrophobic sense of dread as Bruce realizes his heartbeat doesn't match Dick's body, signaling something deeply wrong about this reality. The comic immediately establishes that nothing here can be trusted, grounding the abstract concept of reality manipulation in visceral, physical details. It's the kind of smart hook that makes you keep flipping pages with genuine unease about what comes next.

Recap

Batman was resurrected in a future Gotham after being eliminated from a deadly multiversal tournament meant to decide Earth's fate against Darkseid. He encountered Dick Grayson, who now rules as Batman over an army of Robins from around the world. Dick revealed that Bruce's obsession with being Batman led to his downfall, and the city became a training ground under Dick's leadership. The issue ended with tension building between Bruce and this new Batman, questioning what had really happened and what the future held.

Plot Analysis

The Heart of Apokolips has engineered a psychological nightmare specifically for Bruce. He finds himself facing Dick Grayson commanding an entire army of Robins, testing whether Bruce can fight the one person he always believed would surpass him. Using a Mother Box armor to read heartbeats, Bruce detects that the Dick before him isn't quite right, his heart doesn't match his age. After a brutal confrontation, the facade crumbles and Bruce realizes this Dick is actually a construction of the Heart, designed to exploit his deepest fears about failing his proteges.

Bruce then encounters Jason Todd alive in an Arkham that shouldn't exist. Jason confronts Bruce with accusations about killing his brothers and struggling to handle it the way Bruce always struggled. The environment keeps shifting, with the Heart layer by layer exposing each trauma and fear Bruce carries. What Bruce initially believed was real keeps getting stripped away; even Jason becomes revealed as a puppet made from Bruce's guilt.

Finally, Bruce discovers the truth through memory and introspection. The Heart created multiple realities to break him down psychologically, each one targeting a different fear: that he's failed his Robins, that Dick is truly better at being Batman, that he's unable to let go, and that his methods were wrong. Every constructed reality, from Dick's Gotham to Arkham's nightmare to Jason's accusation, represents a fear the Heart weaponized to potentially make Bruce powerful enough to compete in the tournament.

The issue concludes with Jason telling Bruce he's really Clayface locked in the delusion of being Batman, while Jason oversees an isolated Gotham under a dome containing Joker's irradiated gas. Batman clings to his belief that the Heart is at work, suggesting this reality might be yet another construction. The final page pivots to Red Hood and "Clayface" in battle, implying the tournament rounds continue against these enemies, leaving Bruce's understanding of what's real still genuinely uncertain.

Writing

Joshua Williamson structures this issue as a mind-bending descent that peels back layers of psychological manipulation with increasing precision. The pacing deliberately accelerates as Bruce moves from confusion about Dick's heartbeat to full realization that entire realities have been constructed for him. Dialogue serves dual purposes, sounding like genuine arguments while also revealing the Heart's design. When Dick speaks, his words carry both conviction and wrongness; when Jason confronts Bruce, there's real weight to the accusations even though we know something's false. The weak point is the final Clayface section, which introduces another reality shift but doesn't land with the same emotional impact as the Dick and Bruce sequences. Bruce's internal monologue about Gotham's silence is particularly strong, contrasting what he remembers with what he now experiences. The structure becomes slightly murky in the final act, making it unclear whether Clayface's Gotham is another Heart construction or genuinely real, which reads as either brilliant ambiguity or slight confusion in execution.

Art

Dan Mora's artwork brilliantly communicates psychological unraveling through visual design. The Dick section shows confident, crisp linework with dynamic acrobatic poses that feel threatening rather than inspiring. When the reveal happens and Bruce touches Dick's chest to feel his heart, the camera angle shifts subtly, making readers feel the disorientation with him. The color work by Triona Farrell shifts from the blues and grays of Bruce's internal monologues to sickly greens during Jason's confrontation, creating mood through palette without screaming the emotion. The Clayface dome section shows Mora drawing Gotham with heavy blacks and limited color, emphasizing isolation and entrapment.

Character Development

Bruce's arc in this issue is substantial but paradoxical, which actually works for what the story is doing. He moves from confident certainty about recognizing Dick to complete doubt about his own perception of reality. The moment where Bruce admits he was wrong about Dick potentially being the better Batman carries genuine weight because it builds on years of canon history about their relationship. His reflections on what Batman does to the body and his guilt over the Robins feel earned and personal. Dick, as a construct, still manages character work by forcing Bruce to confront his fears about legacy and control. Jason's appearance effectively uses Bruce's guilt as characterization, whether Jason is real or not. The issue's weakness is that the supporting Robins remain mostly faceless troops, serving narrative function rather than character exploration. The real-or-not Clayface at the end hints at deeper character work but doesn't quite deliver it within this issue's scope.

Originality & Concept Execution

The concept of using a psychological reality gauntlet to extract power from contestants is fresh territory for tournament comics. Most tournament arcs rely on physical challenges; making the tournament component about breaking someone's psyche to access latent power is genuinely clever. The execution of showing not just one fake reality but progressively peeling back layers feels novel. The heart-reading moment as a mechanism for detection is a nice touch that makes the abstract concrete. However, the execution falters slightly in its conclusion. The Clayface section, while interesting conceptually, arrives without the same narrative clarity as the prior sequences. It's unclear whether Bruce has actually escaped the Heart's manipulation or entered yet another reality, which creates confusion rather than thematic depth. The idea that every reality reflects Bruce's specific fears is strong, but the final execution needs another pass to land with maximum impact. It's ambitious work that mostly succeeds but doesn't quite stick the landing.

Positives

The standout strength is how Williamson uses each constructed reality to gradually reveal Bruce's core fears while making readers question reality alongside him. The Dick Grayson sequence is particularly powerful, combining physical action with the emotional devastation of confronting a superior version of yourself. Mora's artwork during these moments achieves genuine visual distinction, with his composition choices making the reader feel disoriented at the exact moments Bruce feels disoriented. The heartbeat detection mechanic is simple but brilliantly effective, giving the abstract concept of reality manipulation a physical anchor that readers can understand. The color work by Farrell actively contributes to the psychological storytelling, shifting from cool tones to sickly greens to complete isolation without feeling heavy-handed. The dialogue between Bruce and Dick, while containing exposition, works because it doubles as genuine emotional confrontation between two characters with competing philosophies about Batman's role. This issue proves that multiversal tournament stories can do character work just as effectively as physical action.

Negatives

The primary weakness is the final Clayface sequence, which introduces a new reality layer without establishing the same narrative clarity or emotional depth as the prior sections. The issue also relies heavily on readers' knowledge of Batman family dynamics to land emotional beats, potentially alienating newer readers who don't know the history between Bruce and these characters. While the psychological horror works well, the issue occasionally sacrifices plot coherence for thematic exploration, leaving basic questions unanswered. The Robins function mostly as faceless soldiers rather than individuals, which weakens the emotional stakes when Bruce supposedly failed them. The ending also commits a tonal stumble by suddenly shifting to a Clayface-focused perspective and implications without earning that shift within the narrative structure. The Heart of Apokolips remains somewhat abstract as a villain, making it harder to feel genuine stakes about Bruce's psychological torture when the entity orchestrating it lacks personality or clear motivation beyond "create chaos."

About The Reviewer: Gabriel Hernandez is the Publisher & EIC of ComicalOpinions.com, a comics review site dedicated to indie, small, and mid-sized publishers.

Follow @ComicalOpinions on YouTube, Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter

The Scorecard

Writing Quality (Clarity & Pacing): [3/4]
Art Quality (Execution & Synergy): [3/4]
Value (Originality & Entertainment): [1.5/2]

Final Verdict

DC K.O. Knightfight #2 swings for the philosophical fences but doesn't quite connect cleanly. The psychological manipulation angle shows genuine creative ambition, and the early sequences with Dick deliver real emotional weight because they force Bruce to confront uncomfortable truths about legacy and capability. Dan Mora's artwork sells the disorientation effectively, and the concept of tournament rounds built around psychological breaking points rather than physical combat is legitimately fresh. However, the execution stumbles in its final act with the Clayface introduction. The issue works best as character exploration rather than plot advancement, which isn't necessarily bad but means readers expecting a tournament arc with clear progression might feel unsatisfied.

7.5/10

We hope you found this article interesting. Come back for more reviews, previews, and opinions on comics, and don’t forget to follow us on social media: 

Connect With Us Here: Weird Science DC Comics / Weird Science Marvel Comics

If you're interested in this creator’s works, remember to let your Local Comic Shop know to find more of their work for you. They would appreciate the call, and so would we.

Click here to find your Local Comic Shop: www.ComicShopLocator.com

---

As an Amazon Associate, we earn revenue from qualifying purchases to help fund this site. Links to Blu-Rays, DVDs, Books, Movies, and more contained in this article are affiliate links. Please consider purchasing if you find something interesting, and thank you for your support.