Batman #161 Review

• Written by: Jeph Loeb

• Art by: Jim Lee, Scott Williams

• Colors by: Alex Sinclair

• Letters by: Richard Starkings

• Cover art by: Jim Lee (cover A)

• Cover price: $4.99

• Release date: July 23, 2025

Batman #161, by DC Comics on 7/23/25, sets up huge stakes across Gotham’s rooftops but keeps tripping over its own cape when it comes to how these iconic characters act.

First Impressions

I opened this comic hoping for clever twists and memorable character moments, but was met instead with a jumbled game of chess where the pieces keep breaking their own rules. Instead of clever maneuvers, I got nonsensical character choices that left the whole story teetering.

Recap

In Batman #160, focuses on Hush bringing Jason Todd into his plan to stave off a deteriorating brain injury, while Damian Wayne enlists unexpected help. Batman reviews security footage revealing Hush's manipulation of Jason to prevent him from killing the Joker, who is crucial to Hush's scheme. Elsewhere, Jim Gordon receives an exploding tablet with a taunting message about Batman saving the Joker, and the Riddler warns Nightwing and Batgirl about confronting Jason alone. The narrative features various confrontations, including Batman battling a new villain named Armori created by Hush, Jason fighting Nightwing, and Damian arriving with Bane to assist Batman, only for Hush to take Damian hostage at the issue's climax.

Plot Analysis

The issue opens in the aftermath of Hush’s latest masterstroke. Robin is captured, and Batman offers himself as a trade, only to be mocked by Hush, who reveals he knows more about the fates of Jason and Nightwing than he’s letting on. Batman and Robin escape with a little help from a colony of "birds" and Damian’s own improvements on his father’s old tricks. Meanwhile, Damian confesses to breaking Bane out of Blackgate - a debt owed, apparently, for past help - which sets Bane loose in Gotham once again.

Elsewhere, Jason Todd and Nightwing confront the Joker at gunpoint in the Gotham Lighthouse. The Joker, ever the twisted showman, taunts them, firing wild shots and driving a wedge between the heroes. Surprisingly, the fight goes so badly that Jason and Nightwing end up fleeing, overwhelmed and thoroughly outplayed, leaving the Joker in control of the situation, mocking them all the way.

Back in Gotham, Barbara Gordon checks on her wounded father, Commissioner Gordon, after the Joker’s violent attack. The emotional core of the issue lies here: Barbara struggles with the aftermath, guilt, and frustration at Batman’s decisions, even as her father pleads for restraint and justice. Their conversation is cut short when Batgirl confronts Batman atop a Gotham rooftop, blaming him for her father’s plight and immediately flaring into a physical fight.

As Batman tries to explain, Batgirl throws him into a chimney, matching her anger with upgraded tech and martial prowess. Just as Batman recovers, he’s surrounded by Huntress, Nightwing, Catwoman, and Robin: each ready to challenge his decisions and actions.

Story

For a book that wants to play chess with Gotham’s fate, Batman #161 keeps knocking its own pieces off the board. The central plot tries to be a clever web of mind games and double-crosses from Hush but relies on way too many coincidences and abrupt character shifts. The big set pieces - a Joker standoff, Batgirl’s rooftop attack, Bane’s reckless release - should feel explosive, but the whiplash in character decision-making fizzles the drama. Instead of tension, I got confusion. Jason Todd and Nightwing straight-up running from the Joker is less “Dark Knight Returns” and more “Keystone Cops.” Batgirl’s snap decision to physically attack Batman after years of working together is jarring. The issue wants to be an emotionally-driven showdown but doesn’t put in the work to make these payoffs believable.

Art

The pencils by Jim Lee are sharp, with clear action beats and strong emotional close-ups. Alex Sinclair’s colors give Gotham that essential moody haze, especially during the lighthouse confrontation. The fight choreography has energy, but it’s held back by odd character body language. Panel layouts are solid, propelling the reading experience at a swift clip, but background details can feel undercooked, sometimes relying on repeated silhouettes rather than fleshed-out environments. Still, when the story moves to the rooftops or the gloom of Gotham’s alleyways, the visual atmosphere works overtime to sell the stakes, even if the plot can’t quite keep up.

Characters

Here lies the issue’s biggest Bat-problem. Batman bending to Hush’s manipulations is par for the course, but his sudden willingness to trade himself for Robin feels more histrionic than heroic. Damian breaking Bane out for emotional reasons is a narrative convenience that flies in the face of his tactical upbringing. Jason Todd and Nightwing’s retreat from a gun-toting Joker stretches disbelief way past snapping. Most egregious is Batgirl’s instant hostility: she not only attacks Batman outright but does so in a way that betrays years of earned trust and teamwork; an action completely at odds with her post-Oracle persona. These characters don’t just make questionable decisions; they actively betray the personalities that made them compelling.

Positives

The art style gives the book a cinematic flair, drawing out the moody, electric feel that’s essential to Gotham. The lighthouse firefight, despite the character oddities, is visually memorable. When the script pauses to let Barbara and her father talk, the emotional stakes are palpable, grounding the issue in the real consequences of all this chaos. Some linework, especially in grimacing closeups or shadow-draped action, offers a real sense of urgency.

Negatives

The plotting hurls logic out the Batmobile window. Character decisions feel driven by the demands of the twisty plot, not organic development. Batman one-punching Bane? Jason and Dick running from Joker? Batgirl smashing Batman into a chimney on sight? Each of these moments breaks immersion and character continuity, replacing believable tension with forced spectacle. Hush’s big “blow up a building” move is pure comic book coincidence, stripping his threat of any cunning. The book wants emotional fireworks but delivers head-scratching moments instead.

---

About The Reviewer: Gabriel Hernandez is the Publisher & EIC of ComicalOpinions.com, a comics review site dedicated to indie, small, and mid-sized publishers.

Follow @ComicalOpinions on YouTube, Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter

Final Thoughts

Batman #161 stumbles hard under the weight of its own ambition. There’s intrigue, there’s action, and there’s gorgeous Gotham noir in the artwork, but it’s all riddled with bizarre character breaks and plot leaps that rob the story of credibility. If this issue were a chess match, it’s one where every piece forgets how it moves.

5.5/10

---

We hope you found this article interesting. Come back for more reviews, previews, and opinions on comics, and don’t forget to follow us on social media: 

Connect With Us Here: Weird Science DC Comics / Weird Science Marvel Comics

If you're interested in this creator’s works, remember to let your Local Comic Shop know to find more of their work for you. They would appreciate the call, and so would we.

Click here to find your Local Comic Shop: www.ComicShopLocator.com

---

As an Amazon Associate, we earn revenue from qualifying purchases to help fund this site. Links to Blu-Rays, DVDs, Books, Movies, and more contained in this article are affiliate links. Please consider purchasing if you find something interesting, and thank you for your support.