Written by: Matt Fraction
Art by: Jorge Jimenez
Colors by: Tomeu Morey
Letters by: Clayton Cowles
Cover art by: Jorge Jimenez
Cover price: $4.99
Release date: September 3, 2025
First Impressions
I was expecting a lot more from the first issue of a new Batman run. Instead, I got a comic that felt like a forgettable filler episode. The story was generic, the characters were uninteresting, and the stakes felt nonexistent from the get-go.
Plot Analysis
The comic opens with two Gotham City police officers encountering an attack on a Meatvan truck, which quickly becomes a major conflict when the truck's attacker is revealed. The situation escalates, forcing a massive response from the GCPD. Batman, of course, is already on the scene, observing from the rooftops. He speaks with Dr. Zeller of Arkham Towers, who explains Killer Croc escaped in a violent rampage after a recent exposure to morphotoxins caused the scaley criminal to get stronger and more primal but more childlike.
Meanwhile, Vandal Savage gathers the GCPD to introduce a platoon of private shock troopers he's adding to the force to deal with super-threats. Eventually, the shock troopers will set their sights on Batman.
Batman sidetracks his hunt for Killer Croc when he receives a call about a gang called the Creeps attacking joggers in Robinson Park. Batman quickly deals with the gang before finishing his hunt for Croc at the nearby Natural History Museum. There, Batman finds Croc relaxing at the foot of a T-Rex statue.
Batman calmly enters the museum to have a casual chat with Croc, convincing him to return to Arkham Tower with Dr. Zeller. The issue ends back at Pennyworth Manor when Batman receives a semi-frantic call from Robin.
Detailed Review
Writing
The writing is the comic's biggest weakness. The dialogue is clunky and unnatural, especially in the opening scenes with the police officers. The plot is thin and lacks any real substance. It meanders from one action sequence to the next without a compelling narrative to tie it all together. The pacing is off, with the initial setup dragging on and the climax wrapping up far too quickly.
Art
The art is this issue's greatest strength. The line work is clean and dynamic during the action sequences, and the character designs are powerfully on point. The coloring is overly bright and distracting in spots, failing to set a proper mood for a Gotham City story. There are moments of visual flair, but they are few and far between, and they don't do enough to save the overall aesthetic from feeling generic.
Characters
Batman himself feels like a passive observer rather than a proactive hero. He spends most of the comic reacting to events instead of driving the plot forward. The new villain is weirdly odd hybrid of Killer Croc and Solomon Grundy, which obliterates the elements that make Killer Croc a unique villain.
Further, Vandal Savage's presentation as Commissioner (a role that never received an adequate explanation from the failed Chip Zdarsky run) serves only as a prop for the weak cliffhanger. The police officers are shallow and forgettable. None of the characters are given a single reason to care about them.
Positives
The standout aspect of this issue is the dynamic action sequences. When Batman is in motion, the art team does a decent job of conveying a sense of speed and fluidity, which is the best part of the comic. The layouts of the city are also commendable, creating a sense of a living, breathing Gotham. The coloring and composition during these moments are the only times the comic feels exciting and visually appealing.
Negatives
The worst part of this comic is the plot. It’s uninspired, nonsensical, and moves at a snail's pace. The lack of stakes makes it impossible to invest in the story. Nothing that happens feels important, and the main villain is so boring it's hard to even remember why there's a conflict in the first place. The cliffhanger at the end is perhaps the weakest I have ever read, offering no real hook to get me to buy the next issue.
About The Reviewer: Gabriel Hernandez is the Publisher & EIC of ComicalOpinions.com, a comics review site dedicated to indie, small, and mid-sized publishers.
Follow @ComicalOpinions on YouTube, Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter
Final Thoughts
Batman #1 is an unfortunate example of style over substance. Despite some great art, the comic is a complete letdown with its unoriginal plot and a cast of characters that are about as exciting as a wet newspaper. This is a limp start to what should have been an electrifying new run.
5/10
We hope you found this article interesting. Come back for more reviews, previews, and opinions on comics, and don’t forget to follow us on social media:
Connect With Us Here: Weird Science DC Comics / Weird Science Marvel Comics
If you're interested in this creator’s works, remember to let your Local Comic Shop know to find more of their work for you. They would appreciate the call, and so would we.
Click here to find your Local Comic Shop: www.ComicShopLocator.com
As an Amazon Associate, we earn revenue from qualifying purchases to help fund this site. Links to Blu-Rays, DVDs, Books, Movies, and more contained in this article are affiliate links. Please consider purchasing if you find something interesting, and thank you for your support.
Spot on review. Huge meh nothingburger with pretty god art that should brought back a real Alfred.
ReplyDeleteThis review captures the heart of Aquaman #8 really well. The emotional father-son dialogue was a strong setup for Arthur’s transformation, and the art elevated the entire story. It reminded me of how small upgrades can create a big impact—like when I tried the best Bloxstrap installer for Roblox with smooth updates here: https://bloxstrapr.com/
ReplyDelete—the performance boost felt like a power-up moment straight out of a comic.
I fully agree with your assessment of this lukewarm comic. But I will say that you were very generous with your score. I’d say even with the pretty artwork, this comic is a “3” at best. The writing is coma inducing.
ReplyDelete我强烈支持画师骑着编辑部上班
ReplyDeleteI get what you mean sometimes a story looks good visually but lacks the depth to keep readers hooked, and that balance of substance and style is so important. It’s similar in real life with workspaces too; you can have sleek designs, but if they don’t support productivity or comfort, they fall flat. That’s why companies investing in office interiors Dubai often turn to specialists like Atech Interiors LLC, who not only focus on aesthetics but also on creating functional, inspiring environments through their office interior design and renovation services across commercial spaces in the city.
ReplyDeleteI feel I must disagree with one point you made. What newspaper might actually be more exciting.
ReplyDeleteOPIPLJIVE INFORMACIJE O BOŽIĆNOM KREDITU ZA PLANIRANJE...
ReplyDeleteOvo nije uobičajena objava koju svakodnevno vidite na internetu kada ljudi daju lažna svjedočanstva i lažne informacije o ogromnoj financijskoj pomoći.. Svjestan sam da su mnogi od vas prevareni i da su lažni agenti iskoristili one koji traže kredite. Neću ovo nazvati normalnim svjedočanstvom, nazvat ću ovo situacijom u kojoj sam živi svjedok kako možete dobiti svoj kredit kada ispunite uvjete i odredbe tvrtke. Zaista nije važno imate li dobar kreditni rejting ili odobrenje vlade, sve što vam treba je važeća osobna iskaznica i važeći IBAN broj kako biste mogli podnijeti zahtjev za kredit s kamatnom stopom od 3%. Minimalni iznos je 1000 eura, a maksimalni iznos koji se može posuditi je 100.000.000 eura. Dajem vam 100% jamstvo da možete dobiti svoj kredit putem ove pouzdane i poštene tvrtke, posluju 24 sata online i daju kredite svim građanima Europe i izvan Europe. Poslali su mi dokument koji je provjeren i testiran kao valjan prije nego što sam dobio zajam, stoga pozivam sve kojima je potreban zajam da ih posjete ili kontaktiraju putem
E-pošte: michaelgardloanoffice@gmail.com
WhatsApp za Europu: +385915608706
WhatsApp za SAD: +1 (717) 826-3251
Nakon što ih kontaktirate, obavijestite ih da vam je gospođa Dejana Ivica iz Zagreba dala informacije. Vidjeti znači vjerovati i zahvalit ćete mi kasnije kada dobijete zajam od njih. Dao sam obećanje da ću, nakon što dobijem zajam od njih, objaviti dobru vijest svima online. Ako imate prijatelja ili rodbinu, uključujući kolege, možete im reći o ovoj ponudi i da se događa u ovom BOŽIĆNOM DOBU.
It’s disappointing when a new Batman #1 aims big but ends up feeling flat, especially with such strong art carrying a weak plot and unfocused character work. A first issue should pull readers in with real stakes and direction, and it sounds like this one struggled to deliver that spark beyond the visuals. Clear structure and purpose can make all the difference in storytelling much like how MI Portal Fone keeps information organized and easy to access so users aren’t left confused or searching for what they need. Anyone wanting to explore more reviews or related details can always visit website for deeper insights.
ReplyDelete